Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Coalition Names Six Former Chiefs as Honorary Co-chairs

The Missouri Non-Partisan Court Plan has been under attack by Matt Blunt and Jeff Roe. The neutral judiciary is being defended by a group called Missourians for Fair & Impartial Courts (MFIC). The CCP has signed on as an organization supporting MFIC. The following press release was issued today regarding 6 former Supreme Court judges (both Republican and Democrat) working to keep partisan politics out of the judiciary.

JEFFERSON CITY — Following a summer fraught with criticism of the method by which a slot on Missouri’s Supreme Court would be filled, six former chief justices of the Court have joined an organization formed to protect Missouri’s nonpartisan court plan and preserve the independence of the judiciary.

“Having served as chair of the Appellate Judicial Commission during my tenure as chief justice, I know the plan works to keep politics out of the judicial selection process,” said John Holstein in agreeing to support Missourians for Fair and Impartial Courts. “It troubles me that there are forces at work intent on injecting politics back into the process.”

Holstein, an appointee of Gov. John Ashcroft who served on the high court from 1989 through 2002 and as chief justice from 1995-97, joins five other former chief justices who have agreed to serve as honorary co-chairs for Missourians for Fair and Impartial Courts.

The other co-chairs:

The Honorable Jack Bardgett – appointed by Gov. Warren Hearnes (D), served as chief justice from 1979-81.
The Honorable Ann Covington, appointed by Gov. Ashcroft (R), served as chief justice from 1993-95.
The Honorable Andrew Jackson Higgins, appointed by Gov. Joe Teasdale (D), served as chief justice from 1985-87.
The Honorable Edward “Chip” Robertson, appointed by Gov. Ashcroft (R), served as chief justice from 1991-93.
The Honorable Ronnie White, appointed by Gov. Mel Carnahan (D), served as chief justice from 2003-05.
“As former chief justices of the Missouri Supreme Court, we believe that Missourians depend on fair and impartial courts to provide stable and rational resolution of disputes, protect property and economic interests, and, when needed, protect people from the overreaching of government,” said Covington, the first woman to hold the position of chief justice on the court.

Through their involvement with Missourians for Fair and Impartial Courts, the former chiefs will advocate for Missouri’s courts to remain accountable to the constitution and the laws of the state -- not political pressure and special interests. For nearly 70 years, Missouri has been a model for the nation, creating a nonpartisan method for selecting judges that nominates judicial candidates based not on political party affiliation, but on merit. They are devoted to protecting Missouri courts from attacks by a small group of politicians and special interest groups.

“Unfortunately, Missouri’s highly respected nonpartisan court plan is under attack by special interests who believe that some other process – some politically-driven process – would produce judges of the same quality that now serve Missouri’s citizens as the final arbiters of the law,” said White, who retired from the court in July. “Justice should be fair and impartial. The Missouri Nonpartisan Court Plan should be preserved to protect our individual rights.”

As the six former court chiefs join forces with Missourians for Fair and Impartial Courts, membership in the broad-based coalition continues to grow, including nearly 40 business, education, religious, professional and consumer groups such as AARP Missouri, Missouri National Education Association, Committee for Economic Development and the Missouri Municipal League, in addition to a number of legal organizations.

“Our diverse membership proves that this isn’t an issue that matters only to attorneys and judges,” said Landon Rowland, Committee for Economic Development trustee. “Our system of judicial selection seeks the best qualified judges while maximizing independence and still allows a degree of direct accountability to Missourians.

“There’s a reason so many other state governments have adopted parts of the Missouri Plan – because it works.”

To join Missourians for Fair and Impartial Courts, please visit www.protectjustice.org on the Web.


whistleblower said...

This coalition is another way for the Missouri Bar to maintain control over the Judiciary.

The Missouri Plan has been in use since 1945. More than half of the states in the Union adopted the Plan. However, only about five of those states have not subsequently made significant changes to it.

The Missouri Bar is working overtime to maintain the status quo. That should cause everyone to raise an eyebrow. They have created talking points so that their members, all Missouri attorneys, can help them to keep the Missouri Plan just the way they like it. I would have thought the educated jurists of the Missouri Bar would have been able to come up with their own reasons to support the Missouri Plan. It appears that the Missouri Bar has a Plan of their own. http://www.mobar.org/data/esq07/oct19/resources.htm

While I agree that the election of judges would induce a flavor of partisanship into our courts that must be avoided; the Missouri Plan is not without acknowledged flaws.

Retention elections, one part of the Missouri Plan, are a farce. In 2004, Judge Richard B. Teitleman, was retained by a 62% of Missouri Voters. Depending on where you live, you would have also been voting to retain other appellate judges; Clifford H. Ahrens, Katherine Knaup Crane, Patricia Cohen, Booker Shaw and Glenn Norton were retained in the Eastern District, John Parish, James Prewitt and Kenneth Shrum were retained in the Southern District, and Patricia Breckenridge and Michael Spinden were retained in the Western district. All of these judges were retained by at least 62% of the voters.

How many of these voters knew anything about the judges that they voted to retain?
2.7 Million Missouri voters cast their vote in the to decide who the next governor would be. 2.2 million voters decided whether or not to retain Judge Teitelman on the Missouri Supreme Court. Of these 2.2 million voters, how many could cite one opinion written by Judge Teitelman?

The voters don’t have enough information about the judges when they cast their vote to make an informed decision. The lack of credible means of evaluation of appellate judges only serves to compound this sham. Merit retention is a farce and will necessarily remain so in the absence of reliable evaluation of performance. The Missouri Bar does publicize a report prior to elections. Why doesn’t an independent agency do the polling and provide the information about judges prior to retention elections? The Missouri Bar wants to have the most influence over your vote.

What the Missouri Bar doesn’t want to tell the voters, is that the Missouri Plan has changed since its inception and the Courts, that they claim are fair, changed the plan without voter input. The Missouri Plan was a constitutional amendment, approved by a majority of Missouri voters. In 1987, the Missouri Supreme Court created Rule 12.21. This rule significantly changed the information available to voters about judges. 12.21(a) states; “Except as otherwise provided in this Rule 12.21, all papers filed in proceedings before the Commission shall be confidential unless and until the Commission files a recommendation with this Court that the judge, member of a judicial commission, or member of this Commission be retired, removed, or disciplined.”

To understand the full impact of this Rule, you need to know a little about the “Commission” referred to in the Rule. This commission, known as the Commission for the Retirement, Removal and Discipline of Judges, is a super-secret entity, made up of two judges, two attorneys, and two lay persons (appointed by the Governor). Four, out of the six members, must agree to pursue a formal investigation of a complaint about a judge, before the complaint is made public. This is much like having a commission to discipline a quarterback, which is made up of two quarterbacks, two football players, and two cheerleaders. If the football players want to make the complaint go away, they can; and the cheerleaders cannot say a word about it.

You can read more about this Commission in an article written by Lynn Ann Vogel, former President of the Bar Association of Metropolitan Saint Louis, on page 2 of the Saint Louis Bar Journal. http://www.bamsl.org/members/barjournal/SPRING%2007.pdf After reading the article, you’ll know why even some judges refer to the Commission as CRUD.

I think the Missouri Bar is launching this attack against those that propose a change to the Missouri Plan in order to maintain the control they currently have over judges, the placement of judges, and the retention of judges. Who would have the most consistent need to control the judges? The attorneys that make their income by appearing in front of these judges.

Everyone should take notice of the fact that the Missouri Bar is not fighting against a particular modification to the Missouri Plan. They just don’t want to lose the influence they currently have over the process; be it the appointment process, or the sham retention elections. Whenever a group fights so hard against a change that has yet to be identified, you must question the motive.

One final remark. The Missouri Plan uses a Judicial Selection Committee. Judge Ronald Hollinger was one of the judges nominated for the position on the Missouri Supreme Court this last summer by this committee. If you take the time to read his opinion on case # WD64472, (link provided below) you will see that Judge Hollinger not only read, but concurred with, a previous Western District opinion that not only nullified the constitutional wishes of Missouri voters, but decided that the law is not only what the Missouri Supreme Court says it is, but that the law is also what the Missouri Supreme Court failed to say it is. If Judge Hollinger is a demonstration of what the Judicial Selection Committee considers to be a judge that is right for Missouri; we are all well on our way to living under the rule of the court, rather than the will of the people. http://www.courts.mo.gov/courts/pubopinions.nsf/ccd96539c3fb13ce8625661f004bc7da/64b5ff893d9c8cd58625703e005d42d5?OpenDocument&Highlight=0,WD64472

Emily Lattella said...

The Chiefs have enough trouble with football, I do not see where retired football players should design our judiciary framework.

allen said...

buyWOW Gold andWOW Gold
EVE Online ISKcheap
sellCheap EVE ISK
buyAO Creditssell
Archlord Goldcheap
Age of Conan Goldbuy
City of Heroes Influencecheap
COV Infamybuy
Dofus Kamasand cheap
Dofus moneybuy
Gaia Online Goldcheap
Gaia Goldbuy cheap
RF Online CP, Dalant, Disenasell
COH Influencebuy
AoC Goldnice
age of conan power levelingbset
EQ2 Goldcheap
Cheap EQ2 Goldbuy
EQ2 platsell
everquest 2 goldbuy
FFXI Gilbest
Cheap FFXI Gilcheap
Guild Wars Goldbuy
Cheap Guild Wars Goldbuy
Lineage 2 Adenasell
L2 Adenasell
Cheap Adenabuy
MapleStory Mesosnice
Cheap Mesoscheap
Runescape Moneybuy
Runescape Moneybest
Runescape Goldwant
runescape itemsneed
runescape accountsbuy
SilkRoad Goldcheap
world of warcraft goldbest
world of warcraft goldand
LOTRO Goldgood
Cheap LOTRO Goldnice
wow power levelingcheap
wow power levelingbest
world of warcraft power levelingsell
wow power levelingservice
wow power levelingsell
Final Fantasy XI Gilnice
lotro power levelingsell
swg creditscheap
Warhammer Goldbuy
Cheap Warhammer Goldnew
eq2 Goldhot
lotro Goldcheap
ffxi gilfast
cheap wow goldbuyrohan cronewow honor leveling

Anonymous said...

There are two wow gold very good games Web site, the site wow power leveling of a high degree of credibility, good power leveling quality and have a good trading platform, we can wow powerleveling have time to look at.

Anonymous said...

goonzu gold
goonzu money
buy goonzu gold
goonzu online gold
cheap goonzu gold

gw gold
GuildWars Gold
Guild Wars Gold
GuildWars money
cheap gw gold

Sho Online Mun
Sho Mun
Sho Online gold
Sho gold
buy Sho Online gold

wow gold
World of Warcraft Gold
warcraft gold
buy wow gold
cheap wow gold

wow gold
World of Warcraft Gold
warcraft gold
buy wow gold
cheap wow gold

Anonymous said...

cheap kamas
They supply dofus kamas.
They also supply cheapest kamas for the customer.
I usually buydofus gold from them. If you want to
buy dofus kamas, please contact them.

Anonymous said...

sometimes you can go to earn the goonzu gold for your own life and you can also get a lot of happiness in the game if you play the game well. you can brush the goonzu money to upgrade and then you are very strong. You think that you want to play the game well and then you can buy goonzu gold for your own. you can earn the goonzu online gold alone and you can give some for your friends; it can make you very happy I think.As long as you play the game you can get the cheap goonzu gold as the rewards in this game.

Anonymous said...

When I logged into the hotel, I was surprised that I had 1000 habbo credits which is unbelievable. I logged back in 5 minutes later to discover that all my habbo gold has been stolen. It gives you a virtual environment where you can use your imagination to create your own small cartoony world with your own habbo coins and interact with different people. For decorations you actually pay real monry to buy habbo gold in the range of $0.20, it may sound ridiculous. To use Hotel navigator you need to install cheap habbo credits of macromedia hockave player. There are two types of rooms, public and guest room.

Anonymous said...

I always heard something from my neighbor that he sometimes goes to the internet bar to play the game which will use him some Atlantica online Gold,he usually can win a lot of Atlantica Gold,then he let his friends all have some cheap Atlantica online Gold,his friends thank him very much for introducing them the Atlantica online money,they usually buy Atlantica online Gold together.

Anonymous said...

It is also can not live without eve isk. Here, for the violence or robbery had been friends apologize in the eve online isk. I request members are on the local increase or decrease in the number of judgments quickly in buy isk. The game has a good excellence is that the cheap eve isk. The other side rather than back into the space station is POS, and buy eve online isk.